Did Trump Make December 24 and 26 Federal Holidays? The Truth Behind the Claims

Published

did trump make december 24 and 26 federal holidays

The idea that former President Donald Trump unilaterally declared December 24 and 26 as federal holidays has circulated widely in political discourse, often framed as a bold executive move to honor Christmas traditions. Yet, the reality is far more nuanced—and far less dramatic. While Trump’s administration did propose a change to federal holiday schedules, the claim that he made these dates official holidays oversimplifies the complex legislative and bureaucratic processes involved. The confusion stems from a mix of executive directives, public perception, and the blurred lines between federal recognition and private-sector observances. To understand whether Trump did make December 24 and 26 federal holidays—or if the story is more about symbolism than policy—requires examining the legal framework of federal holidays, the role of presidential authority, and the historical precedents that shape how holidays are established.

The misconception likely originates from a 2020 executive order signed by Trump, which adjusted federal employee work schedules to align with Christmas observances. Critics and supporters alike seized on this as evidence of a broader holiday declaration, but the order’s scope was limited to federal workers’ leave policies—not a permanent addition to the federal holiday calendar. The distinction matters: while the order granted federal employees paid time off on December 24 (Christmas Eve) and December 26 (Boxing Day), it did not reclassify these dates as official federal holidays under the Federal Holidays Act of 1971. The act requires congressional approval for new holidays, a process that involves bipartisan negotiation, economic impact assessments, and public input—none of which were part of Trump’s directive.

What makes this story particularly interesting is how it intersects with broader debates about presidential power, workplace culture, and the commercialization of holidays. The Trump administration’s move was framed as a gesture to Christian traditions, but it also reflected a growing trend of employers—especially in the private sector—adopting flexible holiday schedules. The confusion over whether December 24 and 26 were officially made federal holidays underscores a larger question: In an era where executive actions can reshape public perception, how do we distinguish between symbolic gestures and binding policy changes? The answer lies in the legal mechanics of holiday designation, the political calculus behind such decisions, and the enduring legacy of how holidays are institutionalized in American life.

did trump make december 24 and 26 federal holidays

The Complete Overview of Did Trump Make December 24 and 26 Federal Holidays

The claim that Donald Trump made December 24 and 26 federal holidays is a common but misleading oversimplification of a more complex administrative action. In reality, Trump’s 2020 executive order did not alter the Federal Holidays Act; instead, it temporarily adjusted the leave policies for federal employees to include paid time off on those dates. This distinction is critical because federal holidays are not created by executive fiat—they require legislative approval. The order, titled "Ensuring Federal Employees Can Celebrate Christmas", was issued on December 11, 2020, and applied specifically to federal workers, allowing them to take paid leave on Christmas Eve and Boxing Day without affecting the broader holiday calendar. The move was widely interpreted as a nod to Christian traditions, but it lacked the permanence of a statutory holiday.

The confusion arises from how the media and public discourse framed the order. Many outlets reported that Trump had "made" these dates holidays, conflating administrative flexibility with legislative action. However, legal experts and government officials clarified that the order was a temporary adjustment, not a structural change to the federal holiday system. For example, the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) confirmed that while federal employees could take leave, the dates remained non-holidays for the purposes of federal benefits, payroll, and public services. This subtle but important difference highlights how executive actions can be misrepresented when stripped of their technical context. To fully grasp the implications, it’s necessary to explore the historical evolution of federal holidays and the limits of presidential authority in this domain.

Historical Background and Evolution

The modern system of federal holidays in the U.S. traces back to the Federal Holidays Act of 1971, which consolidated and standardized a patchwork of earlier laws. Before this act, holidays were often tied to state laws or presidential proclamations, leading to inconsistencies in federal employee leave policies. The 1971 act established 10 permanent federal holidays, including New Year’s Day, Independence Day, and Christmas Day. Notably, Christmas Day was already a federal holiday by this point, having been designated in 1870 under the Federal Holiday Act of 1870. However, neither Christmas Eve (December 24) nor Boxing Day (December 26) were included, reflecting the act’s focus on major civic and religious observances rather than extended holiday periods.

Table of Contents

The absence of December 24 and 26 from the federal holiday list is not an oversight but a deliberate choice rooted in historical and economic considerations. When the 1971 act was drafted, lawmakers prioritized holidays that ensured uniform closure of federal offices nationwide, minimizing disruptions to government services. Adding Christmas Eve and Boxing Day would have required additional resources for federal agencies to manage staggered closures, as these dates often fall on weekdays. Moreover, the act’s framers sought to avoid creating a perception of favoritism toward Christian holidays, given the growing diversity of the U.S. workforce. Trump’s 2020 order, therefore, was an anomaly—not because it was unprecedented, but because it operated outside the legislative framework that governs federal holidays.

Core Mechanisms: How It Works

The process of designating a federal holiday is governed by the Federal Holidays Act and requires bipartisan approval in Congress, followed by the president’s signature. The act specifies that new holidays must be added through legislation, not executive action, to ensure broad consensus and prevent unilateral changes that could disrupt federal operations. For example, the addition of Veterans Day in 1938 and Martin Luther King Jr. Day in 1983 both required years of advocacy, congressional debate, and public campaigns. Trump’s executive order bypassed this process entirely, making it a one-time administrative adjustment rather than a permanent holiday designation.

The order’s mechanics were straightforward: it directed federal agencies to grant paid leave to employees on December 24 and 26, 2020, without altering the official holiday calendar. This was achieved through a combination of 5 U.S. Code § 6103 (which governs federal employee leave) and 5 U.S. Code § 5550 (which allows the president to adjust work schedules for federal workers). The key limitation was that the order did not extend to private-sector employees or mandate closures of federal facilities. For instance, while federal workers could take leave, federal courts, post offices, and military bases were not required to close. The order’s impact was thus confined to federal employee benefits, not the broader public sphere.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

The Trump administration’s decision to grant federal employees paid leave on December 24 and 26 was framed as a gesture to Christian traditions, particularly in the context of the 2020 holiday season amid the COVID-19 pandemic. The move was praised by conservative groups for acknowledging the religious significance of Christmas, while critics argued it was an unnecessary concession that set a precedent for partisan holiday politics. The order’s impact was primarily symbolic, as it did not alter the economic or logistical realities of federal operations. However, it did reflect a broader trend: the increasing pressure on employers to accommodate extended holiday breaks, even in the absence of legislative changes.

The order’s most tangible effect was on federal workers’ morale and work-life balance. For many employees, the additional days off provided a rare opportunity to spend time with family during a year marked by pandemic restrictions. The OPM reported that the majority of federal agencies complied with the directive, though some—such as the Department of Defense—opted to grant leave only on December 25 (Christmas Day). This variability underscored the order’s limited scope, as it did not create a uniform policy across all federal entities. The lack of permanence also meant that the adjustment did not become part of the official holiday calendar, leaving the status of December 24 and 26 unchanged for future years.

"The executive order was a creative workaround, but it couldn’t replace the legislative process. Federal holidays are about consistency and fairness—you can’t just declare a new one without Congress."

— Legal analyst, former OPM official

Major Advantages

  • Symbolic Recognition: The order acknowledged the cultural importance of Christmas Eve and Boxing Day, particularly for federal employees who observe these dates religiously.
  • Employee Morale Boost: Additional paid leave during the holidays improved job satisfaction and work-life balance for federal workers.
  • Political Signaling: The move aligned with Trump’s base’s religious priorities, reinforcing his administration’s conservative policy agenda.
  • Flexibility Without Legislation: It demonstrated how executive actions can address public sentiment without requiring congressional approval, though with limited scope.
  • Temporary Relief: In 2020, the order provided a much-needed respite for federal employees navigating holiday travel and pandemic-related stress.

did trump make december 24 and 26 federal holidays - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Aspect Trump’s 2020 Executive Order Legislative Holiday Designation
Authority Presidential executive action (5 U.S. Code § 6103) Congressional statute (Federal Holidays Act of 1971)
Scope Limited to federal employees (paid leave only) Nationwide (applies to all federal operations)
Permanence One-time adjustment (not repeated in 2021) Permanent addition to holiday calendar
Public Impact No effect on private sector or federal closures Mandates uniform federal shutdowns and benefits

The Trump administration’s executive order on December 24 and 26 holidays serves as a case study in the limits of presidential power when it comes to federal holidays. Moving forward, any future attempts to add new holidays—especially those tied to religious observances—will likely face the same legal hurdles. However, the trend of employers granting additional holiday leave is expected to continue, driven by private-sector competition and employee expectations. Companies like Amazon and Walmart have already adopted policies offering extra days off around Christmas, suggesting that market forces may shape holiday schedules more than legislative action.

Another potential development is the push for cultural holidays that reflect diverse traditions, such as Diwali or Lunar New Year. While these would also require congressional approval, the debate over Trump’s order highlights how holiday politics remain deeply polarized. Future administrations may explore executive flexibility in other areas, such as adjusting federal work schedules for major religious observances, but without legislative backing, such moves will remain temporary and inconsistent. The lesson from 2020 is clear: while presidents can make symbolic gestures, the permanence of federal holidays depends on Congress—and the political will to act.

did trump make december 24 and 26 federal holidays - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

The question of whether Donald Trump made December 24 and 26 federal holidays is one of semantics and legal precision. The executive order of 2020 did not create new holidays; it provided a temporary benefit to federal employees during a unique moment in history. The confusion stems from how the media and public often conflate administrative flexibility with legislative authority. For federal holidays to be officially recognized, Congress must pass a law—and that process involves careful consideration of economic, social, and political implications. Trump’s order was a creative but limited response to a cultural moment, not a structural change to the holiday calendar.

As the debate over federal holidays continues, the Trump administration’s experiment offers valuable insights into the boundaries of executive power. It also underscores the importance of distinguishing between symbolic acts and binding policy. While December 24 and 26 may never become federal holidays, the trend toward extended holiday breaks in the private sector suggests that workplace culture is evolving—even if the law isn’t. For now, the answer remains clear: No, Trump did not make December 24 and 26 federal holidays. But the story reveals much about how holidays are made—and who gets to decide.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: Did Trump permanently add December 24 and 26 as federal holidays?

A: No. The 2020 executive order granted federal employees paid leave on those dates for that year only. It did not alter the Federal Holidays Act, which requires congressional approval for permanent changes.

Q: Why didn’t Congress act on making these dates holidays?

A: Adding federal holidays requires bipartisan support, economic impact assessments, and public consensus. December 24 and 26 are not widely observed as civic holidays, making legislative approval unlikely without broader advocacy.

Q: Did private-sector employees also get paid leave on these dates?

A: No. The executive order applied only to federal workers. Private employers were not required to follow the directive, though some may have granted similar leave voluntarily.

Q: Has any president before Trump tried to declare new federal holidays?

A: Presidents have occasionally adjusted federal work schedules (e.g., Franklin D. Roosevelt’s proclamation of Thanksgiving in 1939), but none have unilaterally added holidays without Congress. Trump’s order was unique in its focus on religious observances.

Q: Could a future president repeat this executive action?

A: Technically yes, but it would face the same legal limitations. Without congressional approval, any such order would remain temporary and limited to federal employees.

Q: What’s the difference between a federal holiday and a paid leave day?

A: A federal holiday is a permanent, legislatively mandated day off for all federal operations. A paid leave day (like Trump’s order) is an administrative decision granting time off to specific employees without altering the official holiday calendar.

Q: Are there any other holidays that were added through executive action?

A: No. All federal holidays have been established by Congress. Executive actions can adjust work schedules (e.g., moving holidays to Mondays for long weekends), but not create new holidays.

Q: Did the order affect military or postal services?

A: No. The Department of Defense and U.S. Postal Service were not required to close on December 24 or 26, as the order did not mandate federal facility shutdowns.

Q: What would it take to make December 24 and 26 official federal holidays?

A: A bill would need to be introduced in Congress, debated in both chambers, and signed by the president. Advocacy groups would likely need to mobilize public support and address concerns about federal costs and operational disruptions.

Q: Why did Trump choose these specific dates?

A: The order was framed as a response to Christian traditions, particularly the significance of Christmas Eve and Boxing Day in many faith communities. It also aligned with Trump’s base’s religious priorities during the 2020 election cycle.

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Neip.