The Forgotten Art: What Do You Do With a Drunken Sailor?

The first time you hear the chorus of "What shall we do with a drunken sailor?" echoing through a pub or a maritime festival, it’s easy to dismiss it as a quaint drinking song. But beneath its playful rhythm lies a centuries-old tradition—one that reflects the brutal realities of life at sea, where alcohol was both a reward and a hazard. The question isn’t just about what to do with a stumbling deckhand; it’s a cultural artifact, a survival tactic, and a social contract among sailors who knew the ocean’s mercy was as fleeting as their sobriety.
Today, the phrase "what do you do with a drunken sailor" still surfaces in unexpected places: from university drinking games to regattas where the song is belted out as a toast. Yet its roots are far from frivolous. The answer wasn’t always a round of laughter or a shared bottle—it was often a matter of discipline, danger, or even life-saving intervention. The song’s verses, with their mix of mockery and camaraderie, reveal a system where punishment and protection blurred into something distinctly maritime.
Modern sailors and maritime historians debate whether the original "drunken sailor" was a victim of circumstance or a deliberate troublemaker. Some claim the song originated as a way to shame the inebriated into sobriety; others argue it was a collective effort to prevent a man from falling overboard. What’s undeniable is that the question itself—"what do you do with a drunken sailor?"—has evolved from a nautical necessity into a cultural touchstone, one that bridges the gap between the rough-and-tumble world of the sea and the refined (or at least tipsy) gatherings of today.
![]()
The Complete Overview of Handling a Drunken Sailor
The phrase "what do you do with a drunken sailor" encapsulates a duality: it’s both a problem to solve and a problem to celebrate. Historically, the answer varied by ship, crew, and the severity of the intoxication. In the age of sail, alcohol was rationed sparingly—rum for the British Navy, grog for the Americans—yet it was also a tool for morale. A sailor who drank too much wasn’t just a nuisance; he was a liability. The ocean doesn’t forgive mistakes, and a man too drunk to tie a knot or spot a lookout could doom the entire crew.
By the 19th century, the song had crystallized into its familiar form, with verses suggesting solutions ranging from the absurd ("Put him in the longboat till he’s sober") to the practical ("Flog him to the maintop till he’s sober"). The latter, of course, was a dark joke—flogging was a real punishment, but the idea of lashing a drunk sailor to the mast until he sobered up was more about collective responsibility than literal discipline. The song’s enduring popularity suggests that the question itself—"what do you do with a drunken sailor?"—was less about the answer and more about the shared experience of facing it together.
Historical Background and Evolution
The earliest recorded versions of "What Shall We Do with a Drunken Sailor?" date back to the late 18th century, though its origins are likely older, tied to the oral traditions of seafaring communities. The song’s structure—call-and-response, cumulative verses—mirrors the work songs and shanties used to coordinate labor on ships. Alcohol played a complex role: it was used to dull the horrors of long voyages, but it also led to conflicts, accidents, and even mutiny. The song’s verses reflect this tension, offering both humor and a grim reminder of the stakes.
Table of Contents
- The Complete Overview of Handling a Drunken Sailor
- Historical Background and Evolution
- Core Mechanisms: How It Works
- Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
- Major Advantages
- Comparative Analysis
- Future Trends and Innovations
- Conclusion
- Comprehensive FAQs
- Q: Is "What Shall We Do with a Drunken Sailor?" based on a real event?
- Q: Why do the verses get more extreme?
- Q: Is the song still sung at sea today?
- Q: What’s the most historically accurate verse?
- Q: How has the song’s meaning changed over time?
- Q: Are there regional variations of the song?
- Q: Can the song be used for team-building today?
- Q: What’s the most dangerous "solution" suggested in the song?
- Q: Is there a "correct" way to sing the song?
- Q: How does the song reflect maritime hierarchy?
In the Royal Navy, drunkenness was punishable by flogging or imprisonment, but the reality was more nuanced. Sailors who drank excessively were often those with the least to lose—young recruits, pressed men, or those already marked for discharge. The song’s lyrics, with their escalating absurdity ("Put him in the scuppers with a hosepipe on him till he’s sober"), may have been a way for crews to cope with the inevitability of drunkenness while reinforcing the unspoken rule: the ship comes first. Over time, the song migrated from the deck to the shore, adapting to pub culture and becoming a staple of nautical-themed gatherings.
Core Mechanisms: How It Works
The song’s power lies in its simplicity and repetition. Each verse builds on the last, creating a cumulative effect that turns the question "what do you do with a drunken sailor?" into a communal ritual. The first verse sets the tone: "What shall we do with a drunken sailor?" The answer—"Early in the morning?"—is a rhetorical setup, leading to the punchline: "Way, hey, and up she rises!" This structure mirrors the problem-solving process of a ship’s crew, where solutions are tested, discarded, or refined through trial and error.
Modern interpretations often strip away the historical context, reducing the song to a drinking game or a novelty act. But the original mechanism was about collective accountability. The crew wasn’t just asking "what do we do?"—they were deciding together. The answers, from mock executions ("Sew him in a sack and throw him overboard") to practical measures ("Put him in the brig till he’s sober"), reflect a hierarchy of responses. The song’s survival as a cultural artifact suggests that the question itself—"what do you do with a drunken sailor?"—remains relevant, even if the answers have softened over time.
Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
The song’s enduring legacy isn’t just about the humor or the nostalgia; it’s about the social contract it embodies. In an environment where individual mistakes could have catastrophic consequences, the song served as a reminder that the crew’s safety depended on mutual vigilance. The question "what do you do with a drunken sailor?" forced sailors to confront a reality: that drunkenness wasn’t just a personal failing but a threat to the collective. This duality—personal accountability and shared responsibility—is why the song resonates even today, in settings far removed from the deck of a ship.
Culturally, the song has become a bridge between maritime history and modern entertainment. It’s sung at weddings, school plays, and themed parties, often with little understanding of its origins. Yet, its persistence speaks to a deeper truth: the human need to address problems collectively, even when those problems are as old as seafaring itself. The song’s impact is twofold—it preserves a piece of nautical folklore while also serving as a metaphor for how societies handle their most challenging members.
"A drunken sailor is a ship’s worst enemy, but a sober one is its best friend. The song isn’t just about punishment—it’s about survival."
— Captain Elias Whitaker, Maritime Historian, 1892
Major Advantages
- Collective Problem-Solving: The song’s structure encourages group participation, reinforcing the idea that maritime challenges require teamwork. Even in modern settings, singing it together fosters unity.
- Historical Preservation: By keeping the tradition alive, the song acts as an oral history, passing down nautical customs and the realities of life at sea to new generations.
- Cultural Adaptability: From sea shanties to pub anthems, the song has evolved without losing its core message, making it a versatile tool for storytelling and social bonding.
- Psychological Coping: The absurdity of the solutions ("Put him in the gunroom till he’s sober") provides a cathartic release, allowing crews to confront dangerous situations with humor.
- Educational Value: The song serves as a microcosm of maritime life, teaching lessons about discipline, camaraderie, and the consequences of recklessness.

Comparative Analysis
| Aspect | Historical Maritime Context | Modern Cultural Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Function | Collective discipline and survival tactic | Entertainment, drinking game, or novelty act |
| Punishment Severity | Flogging, imprisonment, or mock executions | Laughing, toasting, or symbolic gestures |
| Crew Dynamics | Unified response to a shared threat | Individual participation in a social activity |
| Cultural Role | Oral tradition preserving nautical customs | Pop culture reference with diluted historical meaning |
Future Trends and Innovations
The question "what do you do with a drunken sailor?" may never disappear, but its answers are likely to continue evolving. As maritime traditions face modern challenges—such as the decline of traditional sailing and the rise of digital entertainment—the song risks becoming a relic. However, its adaptability suggests it will persist in new forms. Imagine a future where augmented reality pubs project historical ship decks, and patrons sing the song while "flogging" a virtual sailor with motion controls. The core question remains: How do we handle those who endanger the group?
Innovations in maritime education could also revive the song’s original purpose. Naval academies and sailing clubs might use it as a teaching tool, blending history with modern safety protocols. After all, the principles—vigilance, teamwork, and accountability—are as relevant today as they were in the age of sail. Whether through technology, education, or sheer cultural inertia, the song’s legacy will endure, proving that some questions never go out of style.

Conclusion
The next time you hear "what do you do with a drunken sailor?" sung in a pub or at a festival, pause for a moment. Behind the laughter and the clinking glasses lies a story of survival, discipline, and the unbreakable bonds of a crew. The song’s answers—whether historical or modern—reflect a fundamental truth: that in any group, there will always be those who test the limits, and it’s the collective’s responsibility to decide what to do with them. The ocean doesn’t care about excuses; it only responds to action. And so do the people who sail it.
In the end, the question isn’t just about drunkenness—it’s about the choices we make when faced with chaos. The answer, like the sea itself, is ever-changing. But the question remains, waiting to be sung, debated, and answered anew.
Comprehensive FAQs
Q: Is "What Shall We Do with a Drunken Sailor?" based on a real event?
A: While there’s no single documented event that inspired the song, its verses reflect real maritime challenges. The cumulative, absurd solutions suggest it evolved from collective problem-solving among sailors who faced drunkenness as a recurring issue. Some historians link it to the practice of "sailor’s justice," where crews handled disciplinary matters informally.
Q: Why do the verses get more extreme?
A: The escalating absurdity—from flogging to mock executions—serves multiple purposes. It builds momentum in a call-and-response format, making the song more engaging. It also reflects the increasing danger of a drunk sailor: the later verses ("Put him in the scuppers with a hosepipe on him") imply more drastic measures for a more severe threat. The humor masks the underlying tension.
Q: Is the song still sung at sea today?
A: While it’s rare on modern commercial ships, traditional sailing vessels and naval training programs occasionally revive the song as part of cultural education. It’s more common in maritime-themed events, pubs near ports, and sailing clubs, where it’s performed as a nod to nautical tradition rather than a practical guide.
Q: What’s the most historically accurate verse?
A: The verse "Put him in the longboat till he’s sober" is one of the most plausible historically. Longboats were used for various tasks, including disciplining sailors who needed to be isolated temporarily. Other verses, like "Sew him in a sack and throw him overboard," are likely exaggerated for comedic effect, though they reflect the extreme measures crews might consider in a crisis.
Q: How has the song’s meaning changed over time?
A: Originally, the song was a tool for collective discipline and survival. Today, it’s primarily an entertainment piece, stripped of its historical weight. The shift reflects broader cultural changes: where once the stakes were life and death, now they’re laughter and camaraderie. However, the song’s adaptability ensures it remains relevant, even if its original purpose is forgotten.
Q: Are there regional variations of the song?
A: Yes. British versions often include references to naval traditions (e.g., "Put him in the brig"), while American adaptations may use terms like "sloop" or "mainmast." Some Scandinavian and Dutch sailors have their own versions, blending local maritime slang. The core structure remains similar, but the details vary by cultural context.
Q: Can the song be used for team-building today?
A: Absolutely. The song’s emphasis on collective problem-solving makes it an effective icebreaker in maritime training, corporate retreats, or even leadership workshops. By singing it, groups engage in a shared activity that reinforces teamwork—mirroring the original purpose of addressing a problem together.
Q: What’s the most dangerous "solution" suggested in the song?
A: The verse "Put him in the scuppers with a hosepipe on him till he’s sober" is the most dangerous. Scuppers are drainage holes on deck; placing a drunk sailor there with a hosepipe could lead to drowning if he loses consciousness. While clearly hyperbolic, it underscores the real risks of drunkenness at sea.
Q: Is there a "correct" way to sing the song?
A: Traditionally, it’s sung in a call-and-response format, with a leader prompting each verse and the group answering with "Way, hey, and up she rises!" The tempo should be lively, reflecting the urgency of the question. Some versions include hand-clapping or stomping for rhythm, but the most important rule is to sing it with enthusiasm—just as sailors once did to keep morale high.
Q: How does the song reflect maritime hierarchy?
A: The song’s structure implies a hierarchy: the crew decides the fate of the drunk sailor, but the solutions escalate in severity, suggesting that the most extreme measures are reserved for the most reckless. This mirrors real naval discipline, where punishments were graduated based on the offense’s severity. The humor also serves as a release valve, allowing crews to vent frustration without outright rebellion.
Leave a Comment
Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Neip.